
October means only one thing. OK, it doesn't just mean one thing, as there's the Horse of the Year Show, the Booker Prize, the clocks going back, Halloween, the deadline for sending your tax returns by post, and the bank holiday to coincide with celebrating the birth of Hazell Dean. But really, Octobers exist to remind us that the Christmas decor is about to suffocate every shop's innards within a matter of a few weeks, and that what heralds the pre-Yuletide build-up even more than greatest hits albums or the emergence of live DVDs from people who've been on
Mock the Week is a lot of cheap, gaudy additions to the humour sections of bookshops. Stocking fillers. Books to dip into. Toilet books.
If there's something that constitutes a toilet book, it's a tome that isn't really linear. Try starting
Anna Karenina at page 271 and next switch to page 80 and it won't really work, but no matter what page you stop at in
Is It Me Or Is Everything Just Shit?, chances are that your reaction and appreciation of the text will be exactly the same.
I was going to invent a sarcastic spoof title for an
Is It Me...?-type book but then reasoned that, like the names of thrash metal bands, or of porn films, it is impossible to parody the titles of toilet books. The genuine articles cannot be beaten. And so, it is with great pleasure that I welcome on to the shelves of bookstores everywhere a piece of work that aims to make sense of the convoluted history of the much-disrespected toilet book - namely the terrfically entertaining and informative
Closet Reading by Phil Norman, which is subtitled "500 Years of Humour on the Loo". Over 250 pages, he traces the story of how we got from
The Decameron to
Crap Towns, an itinerary with many breathers along the way: conpendiums of riddles, bawdy stories, periodicals, mock-ups of
Radio Times listings, and - fittingly - the borrowings of daubings from lavatory walls (the latter courtesy of Nigel Rees's many volumes of graffiti in the 1980s). Clowns called Roger, farmhands in 1595 called 'John-a-Nokes', the innate feeling that a book by the game and prolific Gyles Brandreth is never far away, regardless of the subject under discussion.
I'd dearly like to know how Norman amassed all the ingredients for
Closet Reading for this well-researched journey. Either he was bought a skipful of pulp each December throughout his childhood (and adulthood?), or he has set out with grim thoroughness to test that reported claim that 'The British Library is bound by law to keep a copy of every book published in the United Kingdom'. Or has he, on the other hand, not logged out of eBay since March 2002?
We've all bought or been bought many titles celebrated or at least eyed suspiciously in
Closet Reading - even if we haven't gone as far as to actually share our living space with
What a Week! with Bruno Brookes or
Angela Rippon's West Country. Admittedly, my own personal collection of toilet books ranges from nearly all the
Not the Nine O'Clock News ones,
The Goodies Book of Criminal Records,
The Peter Powell Book of Pop, and seven annual volumes of
The Rock Yearbook (Virgin Books, throughout the 80s, usually containing at least one ponderous phoned-in rant from Tony Parsons), to a free copy of
Viz's Crap Joke Book (from when I bought a tape deck from Richer Sounds in 1992), Paul Manning's
How to Be a Wally, and - given to me at the age of EIGHT by friends of my parents - Ronnie Barker's
Sauce. I met these people again at a family gathering a few weeks ago, and despite being roaringly drunk and therefore far more likely than usual to ask weird questions, never thought to enquire, "Now, did you ever open that Ronnie Barker book before giving it to me, seeing as it was almost literally page after page of black and white archived photographs of naked women?" And in case you're wondering: no, a song from Barbara Dickson did not turn up for the centrefold.
Toilet books are oft-maligned and rarely given their due, so it's gratifying to see Norman pay sincere tribute to many of these titles. For instance, I'm still not sure if after all these years any book has made me laugh as loudly, as agonisedly, as Stephen Pile's
The Book of Heroic Failures (1979) and its sequel
The Return of Heroic Failures, with such entries as "The World's Worst Garage" (had three steps leading up to its entrance), or "The World's Most Useless Ornament" (the woman who owned it discovered it was a live bomb).
Heroic Failures isn't mentioned in the same breath as
Decline and Fall very often, and I'm certainly not suggesting it's better either, but what I cannot doubt is that few Christmas presents have given me such uncomplicated joy.
Norman's own prose, rich and evocative, demonstrates he's a gifted humorous writer himself. His summing up of Les Dawson's lecherous Cosmo Smallpiece is too inspired for me to toss away on a mere blog post - buy the book! - and I'd like to think that Dawson himself would have approved of his description. Juggling factual material and humour can be fraught with difficulty; it's easy to get bogged down with diligently researched information, or get carried away with witticisms and evaporate into pointless whimsy, but this author has a lightness of touch, a lively imagination and sticks to the point.
Will
Closet Reading become a toilet book itself? Here's the irony. It's not a toilet book, not really. No pictures for starters, you have no choice but to read many words one after another with no other distractions, dammit. No chapter is terribly long, but it's less of a bog book than, say, Chris Evans's newly-published autobiography, which - diverting as it can be - rarely prods any chapter past five sides of paper. It has a thematic structure and is designed to be read from cover to cover. But then again, I suppose anything could be a toilet book, if you so desired. Maybe
Clarissa, if pushed, although only if you were locked in.
Here's a second paradox. Even though I myself have been instrumental in writing a book that became a toilet read for an ex-school friend and his legendary musician flatmate (clue: rhymes with 'Latex Bin'), I don't read in the lav, nor have I ever done really. I have read in the bath, I would probably pack a book if I had to go hand-gliding, but I never think to read books on the toilet. I save that time for some kind of contemplation, even if it's simply to try and remember what I'm supposed to be doing after I wash and dry my hands and leave that room. Or maybe it's because I once houseshared with someone (I promise this is not me) who insisted on keeping lots of issues of FHM in the toilet and rather gave himself away by leaving them open at particular pages.
Closet Reading is gregarious, benevolent, filthy, charming, funny and intelligent. What's more it is the only way this Christmas - unless you can track down Michael Parkinson's 1973 offering
Confession Album - of discovering just what is Patrick Moore's "greatest misery". Plus it reprints a Tarby line about a farting Goon that is so wilfully unamusing that it had the opposite effect and made me howl with mirth for a few minutes. Rescue it from the shelves and read it in any room, on any seat, that you wish. Merry October.